Publication highlights

Go inside our research

Explore a selection of research case studies from the past five years.

Read now
A Crick researcher reading a scientific paper on a screen.

Intro

Researchers at the Crick are tackling the big questions about human health and disease, and new findings are published every week.

Our faculty have picked some of the most significant papers published by Crick scientists, all of which are freely available thanks to our open science policy.

Highlights

Knitting with a thread pulled out - epigenetic changes

How epigenetics fuels genetic drivers in lung cancer

In this study, researchers at the Crick and UCL investigated how an epigenetic change called DNA methylation cooperates with genetic changes in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) using 217 tumour and normal regions from 59 TRACERx patients. This is the first multiregional lung cancer cohort integrating genomic, transcriptomic, and epigenomic data to map tumour evolution in such detail. They uncovered a novel mechanism, where DNA methylation fine-tunes how oncogenes are switched on together by compacting the DNA. We also identified hypermethylated driver genes emerging early in tumour evolution and developed a new metric, Mr/Mn, to distinguish functional from passenger methylation changes. Our work highlights epigenetic drivers with therapeutic potential.

DNA methylation cooperates with genomic alterations during non-small cell lung cancer evolution

Published in Nature Genetics

Published

Receptor for type 2 immunity

Ancient retroviruses and sex hormones regulate type 2 immunity

Type 2 immunity is central to parasite protection but when dysregulated causes allergy and atopy (tendency to produce an immune response to allergens), and influences neuroprotection, ageing and cancer. Researchers at the Crick have discovered two new ways the receptor for the type 2 cytokines IL-4 and IL-13 (called IL-13Ra1) is modulated. One is sex-specific – female hormones repress expression of this common receptor so that female cells are less responsive. The other is through an ancient retrovirus that integrated near the IL-13Ra1 gene of our primate ancestors, which produces a partially defective IL-13Ra1 that can block the traditional version from signalling. This is a fascinating example where an ancient retroviral infection has affected modern human immunity.

Primate retroelement exonization and sexually dimorphic IL13RA1 transcription tune type 2 immune responses

Published in Science Immunology

Published

Lung cancer cells

Differences in immune evasion within the same tumour

In a joint effort from the Francis Crick Institute, UCL and the Netherlands Cancer Institute, researchers have demonstrated that lung cancers consist of different subclones that differ intrinsically in their capacity to evade immune attack. Cancers are genetically heterogeneous – consisting of different subclones – but to what extent this affects immune evasion remained largely unclear. Now, using samples from the TRACERx cancer evolution study, the team have established organoids – mini-tumours growing in 3D - from different regions from the same tumour, and further separated these into individual subclones. Challenging these with immune cells from the patient’s tumour showed that different subclones isolated from the same tumour differ profoundly in their ability to trigger an immune response. This provides direct functional evidence that subclonal cancer evolution has important consequences for the ability to evade immune attack.

Subclonal immune evasion in non-small cell lung cancer

Published in Cancer Cell

Published

Vial with blood being pipetted with empty vials

Tumour DNA in the blood can predict lung cancer outcome

Scientists from the Crick, UCL, UCLH and Personalis have found that a test to detect circulating tumour DNA can predict lung cancer outcome in a Cancer Research UK-funded study. The researchers tested a platform called NeXT Personal, which can detect very small amounts – 1 part per million – of ctDNA (fragments of DNA released into the blood by tumours). They applied the platform to blood plasma samples from 171 people with early-stage lung cancer in the TRACERx cohort, finding that people with a low level of ctDNA before surgery were less likely to relapse and had improved overall survival rates than people with a high level of ctDNA. The high sensitivity of the test meant that smaller amounts of ctDNA could be detected, which prevented people with a lower amount of ctDNA from being incorrectly labelled ctDNA negative.

Ultrasensitive ctDNA detection for preoperative disease stratification in early-stage lung adenocarcinoma

Published in Nature Medicine

Published

Tumour cells

Lung cancer test predicts survival in early stages better than current methods

Researchers at the Crick, the UCL Cancer Institute and UCLH have shown that a test called ORACLE can predict lung cancer survival at the point of diagnosis better than currently used clinical risk factors. This could help doctors make more informed treatment decisions for people with stage 1 lung cancer, potentially reducing the risk of the cancer returning or spreading. ORACLE was developed in 2019 to overcome the lack of biological markers in lung cancer, which is important for people with stage 1 lung cancer, who are normally given surgery without chemotherapy. In this study ORACLE was validated in 158 people with lung cancer in the Cancer Research UK-funded TRACERx study. The team found that ORACLE could predict which patients with stage 1 lung cancer had a lower chance of survival, and might benefit from chemotherapy as well as surgery. The researchers also found that high ORACLE risk scores were linked to regions of the tumour that were more likely to spread to another part of the body.

Prospective validation of ORACLE, a clonal expression biomarker associated with survival of patients with lung adenocarcinoma

Published in Nature Cancer

Published

Immunofluorescent images of TRACERx Renal tumour samples.

Over 40% of variation in kidney cancer behaviour is not due to changes in DNA

Researchers at the Crick have shown that over 40% of variation in kidney cancer behaviour is due to non-genetic factors. The team analysed the DNA and RNA of 243 samples from 79 people with kidney cancer in the TRACERx Renal study, to understand both genetic and transcriptional variation (when the genes are read in the cell and converted into proteins). They showed that over 40% of transcriptional variation could not be accounted for by major cancer mutations in the DNA. Instead, it was happening when the DNA was being read in the cells and converted into proteins. Their research identified four types of transcriptional variation which give tumours an advantage, which could be targeted by new treatments or help doctors understand the risk of a person’s cancer spreading.

Tracking nongenetic evolution from primary to metastatic ccRCC: TRACERx Renal

Published in Cancer Discovery

Published

Chromosomes in blue and yellow

New tool reveals how breast and lung tumours avoid immune detection

Researchers in the Cancer Evolution and Genome Instability Laboratory at the Crick and at UCL have developed a tool, MHC Hammer, to study genetic mutations and transcriptional alterations in HLA genes that help cancer cells evade the immune system. HLA molecules present "neoantigens" that signal the immune system to attack. Mutations and transcriptional alterations in these genes can prevent neoantigen presentation by disrupting the HLA molecule, allowing cancer cells to hide. The tool identified four types of HLA disruption in lung and breast cancer that could result in fewer neoantigens on tumour cells. One type - loss of one copy of an HLA gene - was associated with metastasis. Epigenetic changes, like increased methylation, may also reduce HLA expression in cancer cells.

MHC Hammer reveals genetic and non-genetic HLA disruption in cancer evolution

Published in Nature Genetics

Published

Lung cancer cell.

Why many lung cancer patients who have never smoked have worse outcomes

Researchers at the Francis Crick Institute, UCL and AstraZeneca have discovered the reason why targeted treatment for non-small cell lung cancer fails to work for some patients, particularly those who have never smoked. The study shows that lung cancer cells with two particular genetic mutations are more likely to double their genome, which helps them to withstand treatment and develop resistance to it. The researchers re-analysed data from the trials of a new EGFR inhibitor, which blocks a common genetic mutation in this type of lung cancer. They compared the impact of treatment for patients with either EGFR-only or with EGFR and p53 mutations, finding that tumours got smaller in response to treatment for patients with just EGFR mutations. But for patients with both mutations, some tumours had grown, providing evidence of rapid drug resistance. This was confirmed in mice with both mutations - resistant cells had doubled their genomes.

Mixed responses to targeted therapy driven by chromosomal instability through p53 dysfunction and genome doubling

Published in Nature Communications

Published

Tumour tissue

Limitations of laboratory models to represent patient lung tumours

An important aspect of cancer research is the model systems that researchers use to test new therapies. Within the TRACERx lung cancer study, researchers from the CRUK Lung Cancer Centre of Excellence have performed a direct comparison of patient tumours and a commonly used laboratory model - ‘patient-derived xenograft’ or ‘PDX’ models - in which patient tumour tissue isgrown within immunocompromised mice.

The researchers found that patient tumours are often genetically complex, with many co-existing subclones (groups of cell populations with different characteristics). However, the PDX models often only represented one of these subclones. This over-simplicity of PDX models might limit their ability to predict patient responses. These findings will shape the future use of PDX models in lung cancer research and clinical studies.

Representation of genomic intratumor heterogeneity in multi-region non-small cell lung cancer patient-derived xenograft models

Published in Nature Communications

Published

A vial of COVID-19 vaccine in a blue gloved hand.

Vaccine monitoring crucial as SARS-CoV-2 variants continue to evolve

Researchers at the Francis Crick Institute and the National Institute for Health and Care Research Biomedical Research Centre at UCLH have highlighted the importance of continued surveillance of emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants and vaccine performance as the virus continues to evolve. The research, part of the Legacy study, compared the newer monovalent COVID vaccine with older bivalent vaccines used in the Autumn 2023 booster campaign, finding that both vaccines generated neutralising antibodies against the most recent strain of Omicron, BA.2.86. However the new monovalent vaccine generated higher levels of antibodies against a range of other Omicron variants. This highlights the importance of careful vaccine updates and continuing to complement a vaccination programme with the development of antibody drugs that work against all variants, as some more vulnerable people don’t respond well to vaccines.

Divergent performance of vaccines in the UK autumn 2023 COVID-19 booster campaign

Published in The Lancet

Published

Dendritic cells in pink

Understanding types of conventional dendritic cells in mice

Dendritic cells are a family of white blood cells that plays a key role in starting the immune response to infection and cancer, as well as vaccination. However, it has been unclear just how many members of the family there are, especially as they can sometimes appear under different guises. Painstaking reconstruction of dendritic cell family trees by the Reis e Sousa lab now shows that there are three basic types of conventional dendritic cells in mice. They are called cDC1, cDC2A and cDC2B and develop in the bone marrow from “baby” dendritic cells that already have decided to become one or the other type. These cDC1, cDC2A and cDC2B precursor cells then leave the bone marrow to grow up in all tissues of the body, where they then act as lookouts to sound the alarm upon detecting infection or cancer development. Equivalent cells are also found in humans, arguing that this is a conserved feature of the dendritic cell family across species. The research clarifies the complexity of the dendritic cell system, opening the door for future studies to study the exact functions of cDC1s, cDC2As and cDC2Bs in the immune system.

Distinct ontogenetic lineages dictate cDC2 heterogeneity

Published in Nature Immunology

Published

PCR testing at the Crick.

Will mucosal vaccines work against SARS-CoV-2?

Does infection or vaccination induce nasal neutralising antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 variants? The Covid Surveillance Unit has developed a fast, easy method to test if antibodies in nasal mucosa stop SARS-CoV-2 replicating in cells in swabs from participants in the UCLH-Crick Legacy study. Both vaccination and infection boosted antibody levels in nasal mucus, and repeated vaccinations could enhance this. Importantly, the range of nasal antibodies differs from that in blood, which means current vaccines may not stop infections with new antigenically different variants. The methodology used in the study will make it easy to evaluate next generation vaccines, including mucosal vaccines.

SARS-CoV-2 mucosal neutralising immunity after vaccination

Published in The Lancet Infectious Diseases

Published

A plot on a computer screen.

Why the UK didn't experience the predicted severe COVID wave from Omicron "escape variants"

In the UCLH-Crick Legacy study, the team asked why the UK didn't experience the predicted severe COVID wave from Omicron “escape variants” XBB and B.Q.1.1 (variants which arise from weaker immune responses to the vaccine) in winter 2022, unlike Singapore and the US. They used serum collected from Legacy study volunteers and tested for neutralising antibodies against these “escape variants” before and after the bilvalent vaccine - a type of vaccine which targets the original strain and Omicron strain.

Using data from the COVID Surveillance Unit’s specialist antibody tests against variants XBB, XBB.1.5 and BQ.1.1, they found that neutralising antibodies against these variants were boosted 3-4-fold in all participants after the bivalent vaccine. They also found any prior infection was a major contributor to high levels of neutralising antibodies against these new variants, but participants who hadn’t been infected still had neutralising antibodies against XBB after vaccination. Any 4th “encounter” with another Omicron variant, Spike, in 2022, boosted antibodies against these variants in patients who had had three vaccines. People who had been infected with the BA.1/2/5 variant had similar levels of antibodies as those who had been given the 4th vaccine. In summary, the UK’s targeted 4th dose vaccine policy by JCVI complemented widespread existing hybrid immunity in the wider UK population, protecting against the predicted severe wave of COVID-19 in UK winter 2022-3.

Neutralising immunity to omicron sublineages BQ.1.1, XBB, and XBB.1.5 in healthy adults is boosted by bivalent BA.1-containing mRNA vaccination and previous Omicron infection

Published in The Lancet Infectious Diseases

Published

Image showing calbindin modified by endogenous retroviruses.

Ancient viruses aid lung cancer cell survival

Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) are a specific group of viruses that altered human evolution by inserting themselves into our DNA. Often these alterations do not cause any changes in human health and disease, however in some cases they may impact the way a disease progresses by changing the way our genes function. This happens because ERVs can help to generate new versions of proteins. In this paper, the aim was to explore whether the calcium regulatory protein calbindin influenced lung cancer cells when present in the ERV-altered form (ERV-calbindin).

Lung cancer cell growth and inflammation was compared in the presence and absence of ERV-calbindin. The results indicated that ERV-calbindin aided lung cancer cell survival and tumour-promoting inflammation. On the other hand, ERV-calbindin deficient lung cancer cells grew slower, initiated the recruitment of immune cells called neutrophils and released the inflammatory marker interleukin-8. This creates an interplay between pro and anti-tumour immune reactions. Altogether the reduction in growth and increase in inflammation observed in the absence of ERV-calbindin is a phenomenon called “senescence”. These results imply that the presence of the ERV altered form of calbindin aids cancer cell growth and survival and could potentially pose as a future target for therapies.

Human endogenous retrovirus onco-exaptation counters cancer cell senescence through calbindin

Published in Journal of Clinical Investigation

Published

COVID-19 vaccine booster provides good antibody protection against Omicron

As part of the CAPTURE study, researchers in collaboration with the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) UCLH Biomedical Research Centre found that antibodies generated in people who had received only two doses of either the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine or the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine were less able to neutralise the Omicron variant as compared to the Alpha and Delta variants. They also found that antibody levels dropped off in the first three months following the second dose but that a third ‘booster’ dose raised levels of antibodies that effectively neutralise the Omicron variant.

Three-dose vaccination elicits neutralising antibodies against omicron

Published in The Lancet

Published

Patients with blood cancer found to have lower protection against SARS-CoV-2

As part of the largest study to comprehensively evaluate the response of patients with cancer to COVID-19 vaccines, researchers in the Turajlic lab monitored the immune response of 585 patients with different types of cancer after receiving a first and second dose of the COVID-19 vaccine.
They found that patients with blood cancer were less likely to have antibodies than individuals of a similar age without cancer or with solid cancer, and when they did have antibodies, the levels were lower against all variants.

Adaptive immunity and neutralizing antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern following vaccination in patients with cancer: the CAPTURE study

Published in Nature Cancer

Published

Antibody levels vary according to vaccine type and previous infection with COVID-19

The Legacy study team found that two doses of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine generate lower levels of antibodies able to recognise the Delta variant, in comparison with the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine. Their results also show that antibody levels vary considerably depending on likely prior infection with SARS-CoV-2.

Neutralising antibody activity against SARS-CoV-2 VOCs B.1.617.2 and B.1.351 by BNT162b2 vaccination

Published in The Lancet

Published

Restriction of memory B cell differentiation at the germinal center B cell positive selection stage

Memory B cells (MBCs) are key for protection from reinfection. However, it is mechanistically unclear how germinal center (GC) B cells differentiate into MBCs. MYC is transiently induced in cells fated for GC expansion and plasma cell (PC) formation, so-called positively selected GC B cells. We found that these cells coexpressed MYC and MIZ1 (MYC-interacting zinc-finger protein 1 [ZBTB17]). MYC and MIZ1 are transcriptional activators; however, they form a transcriptional repressor complex that represses MIZ1 target genes. Mice lacking MYC-MIZ1 complexes displayed impaired cell cycle entry of positively selected GC B cells and reduced GC B cell expansion and PC formation. Notably, absence of MYC-MIZ1 complexes in positively selected GC B cells led to a gene expression profile alike that of MBCs and increased MBC differentiation. Thus, at the GC positive selection stage, MYC-MIZ1 complexes are required for effective GC expansion and PC formation and to restrict MBC differentiation. We propose that MYC and MIZ1 form a module that regulates GC B cell fate.

View the publication

Published in Journal of Experimental Medicine

Published